Palermo Pizza

Christopher Limoncelli 2 months ago

Delicious pizza spot in Staten Island right off the bridge! The pizza was fresh, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. The staff was friendly and welcoming, making the whole experience even better. A great place to stop for a tasty meal with convenient access and a great atmosphere. Definitely worth checking out if you’re in the area! 🍕🧡

Mike A. 2 months ago

Palermo Pizza 🍕🍕🍕 on Page Avenue has been on my radar for a long time—I drive by it almost every day. I still plan to stop in for a meal, but this time we ordered takeout. We ordered a large pepperoni pie, a small upside-down pie with sausage, and a gluten-free pizza for my daughter, who has celiac disease. I asked if they could cook her pizza in its own pan to help avoid cross-contamination in the oven, and I really appreciated that they accommodated the request. Overall, the pizza was solid. The pepperoni had good flavor, but it was a little oilier than I prefer, and I like my pizza cooked a bit more well done. It also had a little more flop than I usually enjoy. Even so, the flavor was there, and I’m looking forward to going back to dine in and giving more of their menu a try. ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Yayita Eug 3 months ago

I ordered a delivery; it was gluten free pie, ceaser salad and grilled chicken on the side, she repeated the order for me and I paid with my card. When I received the food the salad was missing, I called them and they said she didn’t hear I ordered the salad and they could send it but I’d have to pay for it. And as you can see in the pictures, they didn’t even cut the pie. My recommendation for you don’t throw the recipe make sure what they send before the driver leaves, and pay in cash. Bad service, The food was ok but I didn’t like they didn’t cut the pay.

Patrick Rooney Edited 3 months ago

They have some great pizza here and I had one of the best sausage Parmesan heroes I’ve ever had in my life ! I just updated my review. I’m sitting with one of the best plates of calamari I’ve ever had It’s hard to get this right and Angelica just hit another home run but she hit the ball out of the park with this one !!!! October 3 2025 tried the mussels and linguine a pallet extravaganza, unbelievable sauce probably the best I’ve ever had ! I have a lot of reviews on Google but I have to keep updating this one because it just keeps getting better and better this was an absolutely amazing meal !!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Phil Gill a year ago

Our dining experience at Palermo Pizza was absolutely outstanding from start to finish! What began as a visit to a pizza place turned into a full culinary adventure that surpassed all expectations. We started with their delicious pasta fazool soup - a perfect blend of beans, pasta, and savory broth that set the tone for the meal. The appetizers were incredible - both the fried ravioli and calamari were crispy on the outside and tender inside, perfectly executed and seasoned. That summer salad deserves its own paragraph! It was so amazing we nearly had a friendly dispute over who would get the last bite. I ultimately let my friend, who owns FC CHAOS BOXING, have the final taste - sometimes it's wise to be generous, especially with someone in the boxing business! For main courses, we enjoyed the signature Sal Special sandwich with its amazing combination of fried eggplant, fresh mozzarella, and roasted peppers finished with a balsamic glaze. The lasagna was perfection - layers of pasta, cheese, and sauce in perfect harmony. We also tried their rica ball special (a delightful surprise) and believe it or not, a cheeseburger that would make dedicated burger joints jealous! Who would